896 pages, Simon & Schuster, ISBN-13: 978-1643139173
High Minds: The Victorians and the Birth of Modern Britain by Simon Heffer is a behemoth of a book, as its 896 pages should tell you. I mean, yeah, I get wanting to inform your readership on the topic under discussion, but DAMN. It would appear that, sometime as he was researching his enormous topic, Heffer decided that ALL of the meticulous research he had engaged in should be shared with the reader who could then sift the seeds from the chaff. Ah…thanks? What he could have done was written several books as part of an ongoing series and cut us readers some slack, for the Victorian era was one of massive and almost nonstop change. Such as the story of political reform, or the decline of Anglican faith and authority among elite intellectuals, to name but two. But all of these plotlines are submerged in this magnum opus and, thus, lose some of their punch.
Which is a damn shame because Heffer can structure a narrative with the best of them and keeps one engaged with his fluid style of writing. His knowledge of his subject and his grasp of the facts are second to none, and after completing High Minds there is not a Victorian player, subject, tragedy or topic that you will not have been informed of, especially the sympathetic treatment of several minor figures that Lytton Strachey and others couldn’t be bothered with (people I would otherwise have never heard about). So if you are interested in the Victorian era then you cannot find a denser or more all-encompassing work. Which, again, is kinda the problem. So much information thrown at a person at once can make their heads spin right off and not want to pick the thing up again for fear of losing oneself in so much detail.
But
keep calm and carry on, for High Minds is
everything one could hope for in a history of Britain when it was Top Nation
not so very long ago. I found my standard operating procedure for reading an
enormous history like this one – read a chapter or section at a time and put it
down, not worrying when I’ll finish it – stood me in good stead (I read seven
other books over the time it took me to finish this one). It’s as if I followed
my own take and treated the book as a series, with each topic serving as its
own mini-book within a larger opus. Oh, and after reading other reviews, I must
warn you that Heffer has a rather obvious pro-British and Conservative bent
that he does little to hide – not that I minded, seeing as I myself am to the
right of Attila the Hun. So by all means read High Minds, but take your time, Dear Reader; the book isn’t going
anywhere.






