368 pages, Harvard
University Press, ISBN-13: 978-0674806887
Germany: A New
History
by Hagen Schulze (translated by Deborah Lucas Schneider) is by no means a bad
book; it is well-written, even-handed and concise…oh, brother is it concise. Need
an example? Okay: the First World War, in which Germany was utterly shattered,
humiliated and made prey for the darkest impulses of its most infuriated
citizens is covered in exactly…fourteen paragraphs. You read that right:
fourteen paragraphs, or about two and a half pages, including all of the pretty
pictures. Germany’s long, rich and fascinating history prior to 1400 is glossed
over so lightly that it doesn’t even serve as an adequate prologue (in fact, if
this book were your only historical resource, you could be forgiven for
believing that Germania didn’t even exist
before the Romans came along and started mucking about).
As
you should have gleaned from this description, Schulze provides only an
overview of Germany’s vast history, which is good if you only want to learn
general concepts and events. Don’t let the fact that it is over 300 pages long fool
you, either; the typeface is quite large and the lines are double-spaced. This
may be exactly what readers are looking for, but I found the vague references
to certain historical figures by surname only annoying, because Schulze is
assuming the reader knows who in the hell he is talking about. I suppose it is
only to be expected of a book that spends a few paragraphs on the Reformation
and Counterreformation. I’m not saying it isn’t a good read (in fact, the
narrative flows quite nicely), but it is obviously a book dedicated to advertising
Schulze’s perspective on certain people and events in German history, for what
Schulze wants to convey is his interpretation of the events, their consequences
and lasting effects on the German people. Thus, if it is an easy-to-read,
one-volume overview of German history from the Renaissance to modern times that
you seek, this is your book; if you already know something of German history,
you’ll be able to follow the story more-or-less ably. If not…then brother, buy
another book.
No comments:
Post a Comment