Thursday, April 13, 2017

“Return to Midway: The quest to find the Yorktown and the other lost ships from the pivotal battle of the Pacific War”, by Robert D. Ballard and Rick Archbold, illustrated by Ken Marschall


192 pages, National Geographic, ISBN-13: 978-0792275008

Midway was the one battle on which hinged the future of whom would dominate the Pacific Ocean. The Empire of Japan was, at the time, seemingly unstoppable, while the American Pacific fleet was on the ropes with only three operational carriers, as opposed to the Imperial Japanese Navy’s half-dozen fleet carriers. Fortunately, two were under repair in Japan in early June 1942, and the last four were sent to Midway in what was supposed to be a pivotal battle for her navy to extend their territory eastwards. However, U.S. codebreakers had cracked the Imperial Navy’s communications only recently and learned of their intentions. Only two American carriers remained undamaged, while the third, Yorktown, was repaired at Pearl Harbor in a Herculean effort following the recent Battle of the Coral Sea. What followed over a three day period, from June 4th to 7th 1942, the three American carriers inflicted irreparable damage to Japan’s carrier force, sinking all four of its carriers and a heavy cruiser with the loss of Yorktown and a single destroyer. It has been called “the most stunning and decisive blow in the history of naval warfare”.

Return to Midway by Robert D. Ballard and Rick Archbold provides a great insight into the battle, the harrowing firsthand accounts of survivors from both sides, and the strenuous search for the wrecks of the five carriers in the 1998 expedition. The USS Yorktown was the only one found, but illustrations by Ken Marschall of the wreck are breathtaking, giving you an idea of how surprisingly good a condition it’s in after over the half a century after she was sunk. The book is set out as a day-by-day narrative of both the actual battle and the search, covering everything from the recollections of veterans from both sides, to the searches for the six carriers lost during the battle, to the eventual discovery of the elusive Yorktown. Return to Midway does not attempt to tell the entire story of the battle of Midway (something that would be impossible in a mere 190 pages, which are themselves at least half illustrations), but Ballard, Archbold and the rest do sketch out the background: Pearl Harbor and the Kido Butai, Coral Sea, and the cryptography which put the Americans in position to intercept Nagumo’s fleet. The hour-by-hour narration of the battle is well done, and Ballard uses the presence of the four veterans (three of them aviators) to personalize the air battles from both sides’ perspectives.

Tuesday, April 11, 2017

“Nicholas II: The Last of the Tsars”, by Marc Ferro


336 pages, Oxford University Press, ISBN-13: 978-0195081923

Nicholas II: The Last of the Tsars by the French historian Marc Ferro is a character study of the last monarch of Imperial Russia that views Nicholas II through his governance and is, all things considered, a rather plodding tome that offers a familiar history of events leading up to the 1917 Russian Revolution. I’ll save you a great deal of trouble and state that the only real revelation to be found here is Ferro’s suggestion (based on the contradictory accounts of the execution of the imperial family at Ekaterinburg in 1918) that his wife – Tsarina Alexandra Feodorovna – and daughters – the Grand Duchesses Olga, Tatiana, Maria and Anastasia – may not have been killed; indeed, there are even documents in the Vatican archives that support this theory, according to the author…IF, however, you would like to see these documents – or any other actual PROOF of this outrageous claim from Monsieur Ferro – tough; you just gotta take his word for it.

But Ferro’s book is more about the death of Nicholas II than his life. It is difficult to determine for what audience Ferro wrote: professional historians will find the absence of footnotes the least of the book’s peculiarities, while general readers will be discouraged by a style that all too faithfully reflects the “Annales School” (a style of historiography developed by French historians in the 20th Century that stresses long-term social history), of which Ferro is a prominent member. The book proceeds chronologically through four chapters, each subdivided every two pages by pretentious headers; the first three chapters tell little that is not already known about Nicholas and seem to have been written only to give book-length status to the final chapter.

It must be said that Ferro ably reconstructs the essential Nicholas: stubborn, shallow and bound by tradition. Though absolutely mandatory, the accompanying social and political explication is awkwardly integrated into the biography; it’s almost as if two distinct titles had been compressed into one. For better, more rounded and thorough looks into the Last of the Tsars, you’d be better off with Nicholas and Alexandra by Robert K. Massie, a work that remains the volume of choice for a general audience, and The Last Tsar: The Life and Death of Nicholas II by while Edvard Radzinsky, which harbors more interesting details concerning the Romanovs’ final days.