Thursday, March 23, 2017

“Jerusalem”, by Alan Moore


1250 pages, Knockabout Comics, ISBN-13: 978-0861662524

Jerusalem is a novel by Alan Moore, wholly set in and around the author’s home town of Northampton, England (and which, incidentally he never left). Combining elements of historical and supernatural fiction and drawing on a range of writing styles, the author describes it as a work of “genetic mythology” that includes themes such as “poverty, wealth, history, the evolution of English as a visionary language, as well as madness, ghosts, and the confusion of dreams, visions, memories, and premonitions”. Oh, is that all.

It is (please sit down) almost 1300 pages long and is divided into three Books: The Boroughs, Mansoul and Vernall’s Inquest. The title comes from the short poem written by William Blake around 1808, And did those feet in ancient time, which was set to music and given the title Jerusalem by Sir Charles Hubert Hastings Parry in 1916. The story develops over centuries and is set in the Boroughs, the most ancient neighborhood in Northampton. The colophon states that the book is based on a “true story” that concerns a large collection of characters, some mythical, some fictional, and some historical. Eh, okay, then.

Along with his family’s oral traditions, life experience, and ideas that he had explored in other writings, Moore’s research sources included a collection of interviews entitled In Living Memory – Life in “The Boroughs”, published by the Northampton Arts Development in 1987, as well as old volumes of Kelly’s Directory (or more formally, The Kelly’s, Post Office and Harrod & Co Directory, which was a trade directory in the United Kingdom that listed all businesses and tradespeople in a particular city or town, as well as a general directory of postal addresses of local gentry, landowners, charities, and other facilities; in effect, a Victorian Yellow Pages).

That’s a whole lot to take in, but perhaps the most important of the many philosophies touched on in in Jerusalem would be Eternalism, a philosophical approach to the ontological nature of time which takes the view that all points in time are equally real, as opposed to the Presentist idea that only the present is real and the Growing Block Universe theory of time in which past and present are real while the future is not. Whew! Thus, Jerusalem is not for the faint of heart or the weak attention span. PAY ATTENTION while reading this book, as there is detail in every damn sentence.

For Jerusalem is an epic of epic proportions, a multi-generational saga of ordinary, working class folk who just happen to have a high preponderance of ghosts, angels and devils among their number. It is also based on a true story: Moore’s own family history, from his great-great grandfather’s visions of apocalypse to his brother Michael nearly choking to death on a cough sweet as a child. A cosmic exploration of the nature of time, existence, the afterlife and the multi-faceted universe we live in, it’s also a conscious piece of visionary myth-making, an attempt to record the Boroughs characters and legends, its places, its past, present and disassembled future, and to somehow save and redeem it all through art.

It’s a long book, for sure, but then again it has to be, for Moore has taken a maximalist approach; he wants to include…EVERYTHING. There are, perhaps, moments when it feels like every scrap of unlikely history and notable figure relating to Northampton has been shoehorned in, but these are never less than interesting and intriguing. All of the digressions are relevant (I swear), as are all of the scenes repeated from different characters’ points of view, because this is one of the book’s central messages: everything is relevant; everyone’s point of view is relevant; everyone’s history is relevant. It’s all connected, man. With this in mind, one could argue that, for all its size, Jerusalem could easily have been even longer; several major plot points are resolved only by implication, and what eventually happens is clearly suggested but never spelt out. It’s up to the reader to fill in the gaps.

Moore has created a fully-realized working-class mythology that is utterly contemporary and (*sigh*) rather left-wing. In an era when the working classes are portrayed in Britain as hopeless victims (by many on the Left) or demonized as thugs and idiots (by some on the Right), Jerusalem rejects the portrayal of limited horizons and the glamorization of poverty that Moore sees in popular culture in favor of a work that grants dignity and profundity to life at the bottom of the economic ladder while also urging them to raise their sights above their immediate circumstances. We are our own final judges, our own imparters of meaning, and in amongst the dark satanic mills of our ordinary oppressed existences, we are all already living in the shining, eternal city of Jerusalem.

Nothing ever ends. Eternalism implies predestination and, so, denies the existence of free will, but as an archangel says to one of the recently dead characters in Jerusalem, “did you miss it?” Free will, like time, appears to be just a necessary illusion, apparent on a personal level but growing less so the more you look at the fate of whole communities, countries or planets. Jerusalem, then, is both a highly moral work and deeply non-judgmental: we largely have no choice in our actions, we are not being continually judged from above, there is no such thing as sin and no such thing as virtue…but at the same time, we should be mindful of trying to live each moment in a way that we can live with forever, because if Moore is right, we may have to.

Monday, March 20, 2017

“The Maid and the Queen: The Secret History of Joan of Arc”, by Nancy Goldstone


320 pages, Penguin Books, ISBN-13: 978-0143122821

After having endured Joan of Arc: A Life Transfigured by Kathryn Harrison (see my review from February 7th, 2017), one would be excused for having been put off by another biography of the Maid of Orleans…but not I, especially a biography by Nancy Goldstone, who is becoming one of my favorite historians. In The Maid and the Queen: The Secret History of Joan of Arc, Goldstone has produced a dual biography of Joan and of the woman who made her career possible: Yolande of Aragon, Queen of Sicily (not to mention a claimant and titular queen regnant of Aragon, the titular queen consort of Naples, Duchess of Anjou, Countess of Provence, and regent of Provence during the minority of her son, she was a daughter of John I of Aragon and his wife Yolande of Bar, who was the daughter of Robert I, Duke of Bar and Marie of Valois…oh, and mother-in-law to King Charles VII of France). 15th Century France was a land in turmoil, riven by conflict with England and by internecine strife within its borders, France by the late 1420s was on the verge of final defeat…when at that moment a French peasant girl appeared out of nowhere and convinced the uncrowned King of France to allow her to lead his armies. Winning victory after victory, Joan revived the French fighting spirit that enabled the kingdom to eventually defeat the English and put an end to the long running civil wars, even though she herself was captured and executed only a year or so after her first battle. That’s the story that has come down to us over the centuries. The story of Joan of Arc has passed from history into legend, in the process losing many of the details that made her so fascinating.

Goldstone shows that the story is true, but reveals unexpected dimensions behind it that eliminate some of the more fantastical elements but maintain and enhance the drama. In short: Goldstone provides an original (at least to me) and convincing argument explaining just how and why Yolande was able to grease Joan’s path into court (I won’t belabor the details; buy the book). Yolande of Aragon is revealed by Goldstone to have been one of the prime movers behind the career of Joan and the development of France during the 15th Century. Her long and active life amidst the extraordinarily complex dynastic politics of the period makes for fascinating reading. Goldstone makes the point that while women seemed to live life off stage, they nevertheless often played important roles through their influence on the men who were their sons, husbands, and fathers. Yolande’s career definitely proves the point, as does the better known but shorter one of Joan of Arc, but Goldstone’s ability to tell a dramatic story will ensure that her life, as well as those of the other women in this story, will no longer go unnoticed. As to Joan’s impact on the subsequent course of the war, opinions range from “move on nothing to see here” to “all hail the Maid ‘cause she stopped the French slide and put some oomph into the French” (and, at least, never lost). Goldstone holds that Joan’s tragic and unjust death had no effect on the war in that it failed to provide a moral turning point one might expect. French court politics remained far too poisoned to let the army do its job.

While “non-fiction historical work” and “joy to read” do not usually appear in the same sentence, both terms are appropriate for The Maid and the Queen: The Secret History of Joan of Arc. The focus on the life of Yolande of Aragon gives perspective to the historical elements of this book, a context in which to understand the times. Instead of feeling like long lists of dates, names and battles, the story-telling makes the history easy to grasp and to remember. Additionally, Goldstone gives respect to the possibility of divine intervention, without making the work a religious argument. Finally, Goldstone shows how Joan was able, by her example, to teach the French that the thing could beat the hated English. After Joan, they kept the French in the game, bleeding England’s finances, until, once the political situation was resolved, they got the job done.

Thursday, March 16, 2017

“Ibsen and Hitler: The Playwright, the Plagiarist, and the Plot for the Third Reich”, by Steven F. Sage


416 pages, Basic Books, ISBN-13: 978-0786717132

Wait…WHAT?!

That’s right. According to Steven F. Sage, author of Ibsen and Hitler: The Playwright, the Plagiarist, and the Plot for the Third Reich, not only was Hitler one of history’s great monsters, he wasn’t even original. Sometime during Hitler’s wastrel years in Vienna he seems to have first encountered Ibsen, during the height of a German literary cult then current that was hailing the late playwright as a “prophet”. One play in particular would gain their interest: Emperor and Galilean (or Kejser og Galilæer in Norwegian), written in two complementary parts with five acts in each part and, thus, Ibsen’s longest play. In short it is about Julian the Apostate, the last non-Christian Roman Emperor and his quest to bring the empire back to its ancient Roman (read: Pagan) values. Ibsen conceived the play between 1864 and 1868 when he visited the Eternal City and actively collected historical material, before starting to write the play itself in 1871 and publishing it in 1873. Although it is one of his lesser known works, on several occasions Ibsen called Emperor and Galilean his “major work”.

All well and good, but does this really mean that Hitler cribbed Ibsen? Isn’t there more to go on? Well, according to Sage…yes. As related by August Kubizek, Hitler’s Viennese roommate in 1908, the future dictator tried then to write a play of his own about a pagan restoration, setting the action on a sacred mountain in Bavaria, the same mountain on which Hitler would build the Berghof, his mountain retreat. That was where Ibsen had completed writing Emperor and Galilean in 1873, the closing scene of which, as Julian dies from a battlefield wound, an aide predicts, “The Third Reich will come!” Hmmmmm…Thus, it should not be too surprising to find paraphrased lines from Emperor and Galilean among transcripts of Hitler’s casual remarks from 1931 and again from 1941-1942. The paraphrases are there, again and again, with Hitler’s metaphors veering too close to those of the play to leave any doubt that he had a literary source: Ibsen’s work. Moreover, as Sage continues, Hitler confided to Heinrich Himmler that the Emperor Julian had inspired his own mission, and the record of Hitler’s casual chats yields praise of Julian on three separate occasions between October 1941 and February 1942. Yet historians have failed to probe why Hitler carried on about Julian.

If limited to mere words, Hitler’s self-inculcation in Emperor and Galilean would amount to a historical footnote, but Hitler fulfilled and exceeded Ibsen cultist dreams by making life imitate art. As elucidated by Sage, when highlighted against the background clutter of everyday events, a series of Hitler initiatives matches Julian’s actions in the play, with the analogous events following Ibsen’s scripted sequence a little too closely for comfort. These likenesses to the scripted plot began with small scale events during the 1920s as Hitler struggled to gain power before escalating in consequence once he seized power in Germany. As Sage describes it, several Hitlerian moves foreshadowed by the life of Julian in Emperor and Galilean and include:

  • His youthful statement of apostasy from Christian doctrine; 
  • His relationship with his niece, Geli Raubal, her violent death in 1931, and the arrangements for her burial in Vienna; 
  • Hitler’s unsuccessful run for the German presidency in 1932; 
  • As German chancellor, his assurance of tolerance to the churches and his quick betrayal of that promise;
  •  A curious mishap during the dedication of a Munich art museum, and Hitler’s speech at that event; 
  • Hitler’s naming of his rebuilt Rhine defenses the limes, in the Roman way; 
  • The destruction of synagogues on Kristallnacht in 1938; 
  • The Nazis’ non-aggression pact with Stalin in 1939; recalling Julian’s peace with the Persian empire, and Hitler’s betrayal of that pact in 1941, shadowing Julian’s breach of his peace with Persia; 
  • Hitler’s original plan to invade Russia, with a baffling northward turn of key panzer units away from Moscow, defying military logic but recalling Julian’s avoidance of the Persian capital by marching north instead; 
  • Hitler’s order to exterminate European Jews under the pretext of fighting partisans, recalling Julian’s similar threat to wipe out all Christians in the Roman empire.

According to Sage, taken alone each of these analogous moves might be deemed merely coincidental, but together they constitute a pattern made explicable by Hitler’s words paraphrasing the script. The cult over Emperor and Galilean provided a context, with at least one German literary critic writing, in 1924, that Hitler was anointed to fulfill the Ibsen script. The dots connect. But wait, there’s more…two more Ibsen plays turn up, as well, in the record of what Hitler said and did; part of Mein Kampf, Chapter 3, is demonstrably based on Ibsen’s An Enemy of the People, Act IV; and at key junctures incidents in the career of Hitler’s top construction official follow the plot of The Master Builder. To be sure, what Hitler did with the plays was no fault of the playwright; Ibsen bears no blame for the crimes committed by his (evidently) most ardent admirer. But the evidence of Hitler following a set of scripts is there, with several enduring mysteries of the Nazi Third Reich are now linked and explained with reference to those Ibsen scripts.

Why has none of this been noted before? Though it has long been known that the Third Reich was led by a theatrically-obsessed maniac, researchers looked mainly to Richard Wagner’s operas as the source of inspiration. By contrast, Hitler never made a public fuss over Ibsen. Emperor and Galilean went unperformed and little studied compared to other Ibsen plays. Few historians specialized in the Nazi era would have known the play well, if at all, whereas Ibsen scholars are not usually versed in the historical minutiae of Hitler’s Reich. If there is a practical lesson here, it is that Hitler was not the first or last lunatic to cause mayhem with reference to a script. The texts impelling today’s fanatics may likewise yield clues to why they act as they do, and what they might do next. Had analysts in Hitler’s era read Ibsen more closely, the insights gained may have spared the world a lot of pain.