516
pages, Da Capo Press, ISBN-13: 978-1885119278
With Musket, Canon
And Sword: Battle Tactics Of Napoleon And His Enemies was the first of Brent Nosworthy’s
books I ever read and I was hooked from the first chapter. Like his earlier
work on linear warfare, this book is a gold mine of information that is easy to
dig out the facts; unlike most of the books I’ve read on tactics this book is
anything but dry, as Mr. Nosworthy tells you not only what the troops did, but
why they did it. He also very good about distinguishing between fact and
opinion and, whenever possible, he uses contemporary sources to back up the
opinions given. This is the first study I’ve ever read that goes into the
details as to why the British battle tactics were able to defeat the French
(hint: he does not, like so many works, say that it was the superiority of
British firepower and professionalism of the troops). Mr. Nosworthy gives us a
detailed look at both the technical and psychological differences between the two
battle tactics and shows why the results were what they were.
The
tactics of the Napoleonic Wars have been poorly understood, but Nosworthy gives
excellent detailed examples from the era showing how each of the combat arms
dealt with each of the combat arms of their opponents. He shows the importance
of morale and how 18th Century doctrine evolved into Napoleonic
tactics. Skirmishers preceded attacking infantrymen, and columns were generally
used not so much for attack as they were for maneuver toward the enemy where
the men would then deploy into line. The French used lines more than has been
generally thought. This system worked against everyone but the British, whose
superior skirmishers kept the French columns in the dark until British infantry
fired a volley and charged just as the French were attempting to deploy.
Nosworthy’s
book goes a long way toward re-evaluating how we should understand Napoleonic
Warfare, and as such is bound to ruffle a few feathers as far as popular
established views are concerned. His writing is clear, subtle, and to the
point, and there is seldom a paragraph that does not contain some interesting
fact.
No comments:
Post a Comment