224
pages, Random House, ISBN-13: 978-0812967852
The Crisis of
Islam: Holy War and Unholy Terror
is a slim, elegantly written guide to the history the Islamic World that put
into context some of the terrorist attacks committed by Islamist groups. The
book was written in 2003 and was clearly intended to explain and put into
context the terrible events on September 9th 2001 when Al-Qaida
suicide bombers deliberately killed thousands of people, including many non-Americans
and even Muslims, in New York and Washington. The British-born and educated writer,
Bernard Lewis, was a professor at Princeton University and an expert in the
history of Islam and the Middle East. His understanding of this area of study
led to him being consulted by George Bush in trying to understand the nature of
the hatred that most Muslims apparently have to the United States of America
despite that nation's efforts to bring peace and stability to the Middle East.
Having read the book, the hopes of America succeeding in this enterprise appear
forlorn to me.
My
recent reading of books about this whole subject has put these contrasts into
context. First of all, Lewis reminds us that Christianity and Islam are very
similar faiths in which the similarities far outweigh the differences. We
should not forget that the history of Christendom has seen many of its own
atrocities. I believe that economic and social factors matter more than
religious ones and get the feeling that had Islam spread to Europe 1,500 years
ago and the Middle East remained Jewish/Christian, the ways of life and course
of history would not have been different. In the writer’s view, the behavior of
Islamists is not very “Islamic” at all: for example, the Koran specifically
forbids suicide – so suicide bombing breaks all Islamic laws – and fatwas are
not contracts to kill (e.g. a supposed blasphemer like Salman Rushdie), but
simply legal judgments.
The
most cogent explanation for the recent behavior of Islamists has been the
unprecedented oil wealth enjoyed by Saudi Arabia which has enabled the spread
of the Wahhabi sect of Islam, which has promulgated a particularly intolerant
strain of belief. Many converts to the Islamic faith have learned their faith
through this sect simply because it is the most active body even though it, to
Lewis’ mind, distorts and selectively quotes the essential message (Lewis
likens Wahhabi within Islam to the Ku Klux Klan within Christianity).
The Crisis of Islam ends on a chilling
note: Lewis points out that Osama Bin Laden’s declaration of war against the US
marked the resumption of the struggle for religious dominance of the world that
began in the seventh century: “If the leaders of Al-Qaida can persuade the
world of Islam to accept their views and their leadership, then a long and
bitter struggle lies ahead, and not only for America…And a dark future awaits
the world, especially the part of it that embraces Islam.”
No comments:
Post a Comment