320
pages, St. Martin's Press, ISBN-13: 978-0312357856
I like to recommend books I have
greatly enjoyed or from which I've learned a lot. But I find that is not quite
possible with Versailles: A Biography of a Palace. This is not a coffee table picture
book of Versailles; there are plenty of those to be had. What's been missing
from the literature on this subject has been a book that explains the workings
of the palace, its social and political context and the routines and rhythms of
day-to-day life in what was, essentially, an enormous gilded cage for the
French nobility. I was looking for a more human history than what this book
presents. It would have been interesting to learn about all the artisans, chefs
and gardeners that were hired to work at the palace. There are chunks of this
book that are so dry it is hard to plough through. In the early chapters, the
author describes at length the process of building the palace, but lacking
illustrations or maps of the palace, I found it difficult to follow. The palace
was always intended as a showcase to promote all things French: from the lace
on the sleeve to the china on the table to the high tech engineering of the
fountains, and although the tapestries and porcelains are mentioned, I would
have liked to have learned more about how important these were and how things
were acquired for the palace (hell, the mirrors alone deserve a book of their
own). I expected to come out of reading this book with a feeling of how this
palace and home came together and how humans (including kings) lived their
daily and private lives there, with the everyday niceties and problems, but
this is not what this book is about.
The expansive title and good
press that accompanied this book promised an interesting history of the palace
of Versailles, but, unfortunately, it reads more along the lines of an abridged
version of the Memoirs of the Duc de Saint-Simon. While there are numerous
anecdotes of the various people that lived at Versailles, they can be read
elsewhere in greater detail with more relevance to their significance to
society and history. There is no order to what is written, and while the author
jumps back and forth across decades, the focus is primarily that of the reign
of Louis XIV. There is little or no mention of Marley or the evolution of the
Trianon’s under Louis XIV, the petites apartments of Louis XV, the Petit
Trianon, Hamlet, and gardens of Marie Antoinette much less the inventiveness
that accompanied their creation. There is little history post revolution that
could include fascinating stories from Napoleon through the end of WWI. The
history that would complement and illustrate the lives of the people that made
Versailles the center of European culture for decades is lacking. Surely there
are better books that capture these details and tell a more complete story of
Versailles. Unfortunately this is not one of them as it never appears to aspire
to be more than what the Duc de Saint-Simon saw and wrote about in his
lifetime.
No comments:
Post a Comment