304
pages, Simon & Schuster, ISBN-13: 978-1416567622
The Caliph’s
Splendor: Islam and the West in the Golden Age of Baghdad details the history of the early
Islamic Empire and so, naturally, there is much focus on the rulers of said
empire – the Caliphs – and the intrigues of the royal court, but Benson Bobrick,
the author, also discusses the development of Islamic science and culture, the
architecture of major cities, and even the eating habits of the ordinary
citizen. Additionally, one whole chapter is devoted to Charlemagne and how the “dark
ages” of Europe compared with the splendor of Baghdad (hint: not well at all).
This
is a lot of history to cover in just 244 pages and, as so much history is
crammed into each page, The Caliph’s
Splendor takes not a little effort to read. I give Bobrick credit for not resorting
to invention or sensationalism, but there is much that is dry by way of
numerous, lengthy in-text lists (of spices, trades, ethnicities, etc.); the
many anecdotes and quotes from contemporary or near-contemporary sources concerning
the caliphs and others; and Abbasid society that are clearly somewhat contrived
(by the authors of antiquity) if not entirely apocryphal (lore with political
purpose; story of Arabs burning thousands of papyri in Egypt to heat the Roman
baths for their luxuriance uncritically stated as fact); discussions of Umayyad
al-Andalus, Byzantium, the Franks seem rather starkly tangential; and the few
illustrations, although colorful, are merely a hastily assembled and rather
incoherent handful. The more you read, the more you wonder about the book’s
alluring title.
I
wouldn't call this book an eye-opener, and certainly not the last word on the
early Islamic empire, but it does manage to keep our interest – when it's not
raising our eyebrows, as when the author equates the Delhi Sultanate with the Mughals (“Moghuls”). As an excellent coda to The Caliph’s Splendor, I recommend What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam and Modernity in the Middle
East and The Crisis of Islam: Holy
War and Unholy Terror (both by Bernard Lewis and both reviewed by me on October
3rd, 2013); both books document the decline of the Islamic Empire,
particularly its science. All of these books take effort to read, but all are also
well worth the effort.
No comments:
Post a Comment