650
pages, W. W. Norton & Company, ISBN-13: 978-0393040173
In
his landmark (and controversial) book The
Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor, David
Landes, retired history and economics professor from Harvard University, has
written an epic and grandiose work of economic history that attempts nothing
less than to explain why some societies were economically successful and why
others were not over the last 1000 years. He has not retired, however, from
academic controversy, for in the politically correct discourse that passes for
open debate in today’s universities, it simply is not fashionable to attribute
economic success to cultural factors. Landes doesn’t hesitate to demolish along
the way arguments of those who explain the West’s success in terms of
exploitation of the Third World, imperialism, colonialism, and racism; these
may have been symptoms of the West’s success, but not the causes. The breadth
of this work is staggering as he covers not only economics, but technology,
religion, military history, cultural practices, politics, and geography.
Though
the scope of this work may be vast, the author’s assurance never falters as he manages
to find just the right balance between sweeping overview and illuminating
insight. His views are often fresh and arresting, as, for example, when he
identifies the technological factors in Medieval Europe that laid the
foundation for take-off and sustained economic and industrial growth from the 15th
Century onwards. He is particularly impressive on the theme of why the West
achieved worldwide dominance in the last half-millennium, not just in terms of
outright power and wealth, but of thought and values, as well, and on why
potential competitors – such as China and India – got left behind. The
treatment of the First and Second Industrial Revolutions, and of the relative
fall and rise of Britain and Germany in the process, is especially enjoyable; also
effective is the treatment of the success of Japan in making the transition to
an industrialized society, this being very interestingly counterpointed with
the failure of Mohammed Ali’s Egypt to do the same. One’s enjoyment of the book
is enhanced by the fact that the writer does not hesitate to state his case
with strength and conviction, and is obviously not concerned with concessions
to transient fashions in historical retrospectively. One may not agree with
each and every opinion or viewpoint but it is a pleasure to see them expounded
with such conviction, energy and elegance.
The
problem some readers may have with The
Wealth and Poverty of Nations is that Landes gives an unvarnished, no-holds-barred,
tell-it-like-it-is, narrative; many individuals (to say nothing of nation
states) want to blame everyone but themselves for their short comings. But that’s
what made this book so valuable (the only part I might disagree with is the
implied generalization that some groups of immigrants to the United States do
well because of their homeland’s culture; I believe that many of those that emigrate
to this country are a sub-set, a non-representative group that is NOT a cross
section of their home population, a select group of entrepreneurs, risk takers,
or else the desperate, and are looking to make a killing or else have nothing
to lose and take risk and make it big or else fail trying and try again). Reality
can be a bitter pill to swallow, but this is Landes’ topic in a nutshell: This is how things are, not how we would
like them to be. The West is dominant; capitalism has triumphed; socialism
has failed; Imperialism spread much that was good and, yes, was concerned with material
profit (and there is nothing wrong with this: “God, Gold and Glory”, to quote
Landes). Like it or not, this is simply the honest-to-God truth. This book
contains not only lessons but solutions to anyone who wants to see them and should
be required reading for every political candidate, from dog catcher to
President.
No comments:
Post a Comment