601
pages, Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., ISBN-13: 978-0679402305
It
has been said, or course, that history is written by the winners, and sometimes
the losers can get a very bad press, indeed. The truth of this statement can be
found in the tale of Tzu Hsi, the last Dowager Empress of China, who has been
seen as a combination of Lucrezia Borgia, Fu Manchu, and Richard III, but the
truth was rather different.
In
Dragon Lady: The Life and Legend of the
Last Empress of China, Sterling Seagrave tells the true story of Tzu Hsi, this
infamous Empress Dowager who dominated the Qing court for almost half a
century. He goes entirely against the views of earlier biographers who have labeled
Tzu Hsi as an evil genius in order to give a story of a fairly ordinary woman
overwhelmed by the nearly impossible task of trying to reform a failing dynasty
against intense opposition from the reactionary Manchu noblemen. Familiar
events to students of Qing dynasty history (such as the Tung Chih era, the
Hundred Days Reform, and the Boxer Rebellion) are all here, but these events,
especially the last, are treated quite differently by Seagrave, who tells a
story entirely different from most accounts. Seagrave also goes into some
detail regarding the lives and characters of George Morrison and Edmund
Backhouse, China “experts” and correspondents for the London Times, who are the
primary creators of the traditional accounts of Tzu Hsi’s supposed crimes (Backhouses’
extravagantly pornographic accounts are particularly bizarre; it’s incredible
that he could have ever been taken seriously as a historical source).
Not
having read these authors accounts of the supposed excesses in the behavior of
Empress Tzu Hsi, I can only comment on Seagrave’s version of events. The life
story of the Empress is a fascinating one, worthy of the telling, and the sources
of Seagrave’s research appear stand up to fairly close examination. It is a
detailed history spreading through the eight decades of her life, so if you
pick up this book because you enjoyed the movie 55 days at Peking (y’know, as I did) then you are in for a
disappointment (the Siege of the Legations was apparently something of a sham
with the principle Chinese general, charged with the of taking the Legations,
spending a fair amount of his efforts giving assistance and succor to the
defenders rather than bringing about their downfall). I was left with a
somewhat pitiable final impression of Tzu Hsi that I feel has a significant
parallel with the fate of her country during her lifetime. Never a prime mover
of events, she, like China, was much more a victim of Manchu intrigue and
obsolescence rather than European duplicity and greed.
Overall
this is a worthy and much needed reassessment of Tzu Hsi. While some people
criticize the history, the distortion over the events and character of Tzu Hsi
still rage today (the Backhouse bio attributes some sexual exploits of the author
so is completely suspect, but it was taken as gospel for years). Seagrave is
more balanced, and shows the various sides of the despotic but venerated rulers
who tried to stem the tide of modernism in Old China, and failed. The onslaught
of the Western culture broke down centuries of stable peasant culture, making
way for the Revolution. An interesting look into the last remnants of Imperial
China.
No comments:
Post a Comment