368
pages, Harper Perennial, ISBN-13: 978-0060925819
Conventional
wisdom once told us that there the Middle Ages was a time of stagnation rather
than of innovation, but Frances and Joseph Gies make a strong argument, with
many examples, in their book, Cathedral,
Forge & Waterwheel: Technology & Invention in the Middle Ages, that
technological developments from 500 to 1500 AD transformed Europe and enabled
both the Renaissance and the European conquest of the rest of the world.
At
the fall of the Roman Empire around 500 AD, Europe was little more than an
illiterate, rural backwater. Except for a few items left behind by the Romans,
virtually all of mankind's significant technology was in the hands and minds of
the Chinese, Indians and Arabs. European towns north of Rome were small and
dirty, and produced little except subsistence level farming. However by 1500,
the end of the Middle Ages, Europeans had thrown back a major Muslim invasion,
lived in large cities and fortified castles, carried on an active trade with
China, India and Arabia, had developed full-rigged ships and navigation
instruments capable of crossing the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, and developed
weapons that would soon enable them to conquer almost every other civilization
on Earth. Admittedly much of the new technology originated in China and Arabia,
but the Europeans refined it, improved upon it, and put it to practical uses
such that by 1100 AD Europe surpassed its eastern neighbors in sea faring,
agriculture, armaments and day-to-day business practices. Even mundane skills
like bookkeeping, credit, and insurance proved important in that they created
the means to finance undertakings far beyond the capabilities of any one
merchant family or sea captain.
That
said, Cathedral, Forge, and Waterwheel is a book that will appeal mostly to
those who have an interest in the subject. It largely ignores the wars and
plagues of the Middle Ages and concentrates instead on technological
development and the lives of common people. The first two chapters (there are
only seven chapters in 300 pages of text) are mostly background information on the
beginning of the Middle Ages and the migration of technology from Arabia and
China into Europe, and can be a little tedious to read. The text picks up in
the third chapter when the authors begin to describe peasant life in the
medieval villages, and these descriptions are at least as interesting as the
technology improvements. Each chapter builds on its predecessor and we learn
why women carried the ubiquitous spinster around all day; of the prestige of
being the village blacksmith or master mason; of the impact of the first
printed books; and how the appeal of a trading economy spurred changes that
improved everyone's life. Well, almost everyone’s.
Because
the text addresses both people and technology, it is not necessarily riveting
for every reader. You have to wade through descriptions of technology and
engineering to get to the good stuff about the people – or read through stuff
about medieval villagers to get to the good parts about technology, depending
on your point of view. But Frances and Joseph Gies know their stuff and this is
a great description of the impact of developing technology. Between them they
have authored or co-authored more than twenty books on European and American
history, and are among our foremost scholars on Europe in the Middle Ages.
No comments:
Post a Comment