282
pages, Charles Scribner’s Sons, ISBN-13: 978-0684144023
Conspiracy, suspicion, power,
corruption, poison, conquests, marauders, murders, and yet more murders; such
is the history of Roman Empire. Then again, there are copious examples from
every nation’s history of such dastardly acts to grab power, from Egyptians Pharaohs,
to French Bourbons, to Indian Moguls, to British royals, and so on and so forth.
Human nature has changed very little in two thousand years. Now instead of
murdering opponents, we vilify them to such an extent that populace loathes and
discards them in the garbage bin. It is hard to imagine for us with two
thousand years separation what we would do if we were given absolute power over
everybody and everything.
While a fine communicator, Grant
can be a challenging read, given his vocabulary usage; more troubling to this
reader is the lack of footnotes and end notes only which complicates reading
this work, specifically because some, but not all, quotes from ancient authors
are unattributed in the text, as I suspect that most readers do not have the background
in the Greek and Latin classics to easily identify the authors of these unattributed
quotes. Also, a woefully-lacking suggested reading list of secondary materials
is included.
The book opens with a splendid
and extended essay on classical sources, biography, history and things Roman.
It alerts the reader to many facts and interpretations that make the subsequent
text far more intelligible. This opening, coupled with a short but deeply
insightful conclusion, can be read with immense profit without ever even
approaching the body of the work. However, this would be a grave mistake, as
the twelve short biographies in chronological order provide a fascinating
overview of the first 100-odd years of the Roman Empire as viewed from its
center and through the personages of its rulers. Therein lays both the strength
and weakness of the book. Others have devoted thousands of pages to materials
Grant covers in limited and truncated form in a few hundred pages.
And within those twelve short
biographies, I believe he accomplishes much. By Suetonius’s standards, Grant
provides us with a sober and coherent explanation of the problems and
challenges faced by those emperors. That overwork and fear of assassinations
were debilitating to all that ruled long enough is made plain in these pages.
The Senatorial nobility would sooner or later tire of any ruler and plot
against him. And if overwork and sedition by the nobility in Rome were not
enough, by the middle of the period under consideration, the Praetorian Guard
would start installing emperors, and this would be followed by emperors
installed by the provincial legions. In spite of the brevity of each portrait,
many incisive judgments regarding each of these personalities are rendered
convincingly by Grant. I find those judgments valuable to an overall
understanding of the formative era of the Roman Empire. Within its limitations,
this is a marvelous work that can be appreciated by those with a modest
knowledge of the Roman world. Equally, there is much of interest here for the well-read
in this area. A careful consideration of this work will reward the diligent
reader with some remarkable insights on early Roman imperial rule.
No comments:
Post a Comment