340
pages, El Paso Norte Press, ISBN-13: 978-0976072614
Caesar’s
Commentaries are
an essential read for anyone who aspires to a good education. For several
centuries, English public schools (meaning private) required their students to
translate Caesar’s Commentaries from
the original Latin; since the decline of written Latin for church and scholarly
purposes, translating Caesar has fallen out of favor. But the main reasons for
reading Caesar still persist: It provides an excellent model of clear, simple
exposition and demonstrates how a man of substance should express himself. Make
no mistake about it, Caesar was a clever, calculating, complicated man, but
when he wrote, he was certain about what he intended to say and said it.
MacDevitt’s translation is not that of a schoolboy; it is that of a schoolmaster;
where there is a subtle reference in Caesar’s prose, MacDevitt captured it in
his English translation clearly and succinctly.
There
are eight “books” in the Commentaries,
each comprising about 15-25 pages with each book a reflection on the previous
year’s effort in Gaul. The style is plain and to the point, written in order to
curry favor in Rome and document his campaigns. Though Caesar is often guilty
of inflating enemy numbers (according to most historians) he nevertheless painstakingly
records the relations between the tribes of the time: Gauls, Celts, and the
many Germanic peoples are all referenced at one time or another. The final
three books regarding the Civil War are longer, as they were meant by Caesar to
record his justification for launching the Civil War in the first place. How convinced
you are by his arguments rather depends on what you think of Caesar.
It
is a very interesting read, but can be hard to follow if you are not a history
buff or a fan of Roman History and/or Caesar, but if you want to get a real
sense of history with first-hand knowledge, then this is a great read, for when
you read Caesar’s Commentaries, you
are not reading the ranting’s of a third-rate politician: you are reading the
words of one of the most important figures in the entire history of the human
race. The accomplishments of Julius Caesar, whether for good or evil, will
stand as a monument to human ambition for all time.
No comments:
Post a Comment