1188 pages, Athenaeum, ISBN-13:
978-0689119347
The
hero of David Lean's cinematic masterpiece of 1962 is unforgettable to anyone
who has seen this marvelous movie, and in this volume Jeremy Wilson attempts a
meticulous, factual biography of T. E. Lawrence. His book provides a less
romantic portrayal of Lawrence, who however remains a towering and distinctive
personality, but emerges more as a tragic hero than the movie character. Wilson
shows Lawrence's compromises with the diplomatic maneuverings of Britain and
France come to the fore in this book. Another interesting chapter of Lawrence's
life (not shown in the movie) is his own writings. This book explains the
context in which Lawrence's own work Seven
Pillars of Wisdom came into being (a book Lawrence himself did not like
after he learned that good writing is clear writing). I wouldn't have – and a
lot of you reading this review, either – wouldn't have come to this book
without the movie, so I would like to mention some things that the movie was
wrong about, according to this book. 1) T. E. Lawrence did have to execute an
Arab with his pistol, but he DID feel remorse about it and did NOT experience a
perverse pleasure at it. 2) He was not homosexual; in fact, he asked a girl to marry
him, who turned him down (it wasn’t unusual in that era that an educated
Englishman still be a virgin in his mid-20’s, and the only reason he stayed a virgin
until his death in his 40’s was that he was raped by those Turks, as is obliquely
referred to in the movie, and as a consequence was tragically repulsed by
physical human contact thereafter. So he became, as he himself described it, “a
lay monk”). While there have been several other books on Lawrence, this one is
easily one that serves as the basic reference, and which looks at other
biographies, some of which questions Lawrence's own accounts of his life. In
one of two appendices, for example, Wilson takes up a controversy surrounding
the veracity of Lawrence's claim and torture at Deraa (which is strongly hinted
in the scene in the movie where Lawrence is tortured by his Turkish captors). A
first-rate book for anyone interested in the heroic Laurence, which I say
heroic because after taking Aquaba, he was up for a Victoria's Cross, England's
highest military honor, but as he needed an English witness to the event, when
only Arabs witnessed it, he didn’t receive such a prestigious decoration – and
Lawrence didn’t care. He perhaps, then, wasn't as vain as the movie portrayed
him to be, either.
No comments:
Post a Comment