432 pages, Overlook Press, ISBN-13:
978-1585676415
Hugh
Pope's Sons of the Conquerors: The Rise
of the Turkic World provides the Western reader a glimpse into a different
reality of world history. Under-emphasized and under-represented in any history
curriculum at any Western university, this work presents to the reader facts
and events of pan-Turkic and central Asian history and culture that have had
little currency, recognition or understanding in the West. Comparatively
speaking, the history and culture of East Asia – Chinese history, Japanese
history, Korean history and the history of Southeast Asia – are much better
taught and understood in the West than the history of the Turkic peoples in
central Asia. A major strength (but also the major weakness) of Pope's work is
his concentration on Turkey and Turkish history and culture, especially the
Ottoman period and 20th Century, post-Ataturk Turkey. This is
understandable because Pope has clearly spent more time, done more research and
has more knowledge of Turkey than of the other pan-Turkish cultures of central
Asia. In Sons of the Conquerors Pope
does not limit himself to documenting Turkey. Instead, he has attempted to
bring in the many central Asian nations associated with pan-Turkic culture,
i.e., Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, etc. As a reader, I
would have liked to see more equal time spent on the cultures of these central
Asian nations, many of them newly minted from the breakup of the Soviet Union
in the early 1990s. Among these, Uzbekistan is slightly favored with extra
time. In addition, Pope gives short shrift to Turkic peoples living within
today's post-Soviet Russia, i.e., Tatars and the Buryats to name two groups. This
is a good read, especially for someone reading about Turkic history for the
first time. However, the serious student will need more than is presented here,
especially about the central Asian pan-Turkic peoples.
No comments:
Post a Comment