704 pages, Basic Books, ISBN-13:
978-0465023967
Though
more people today associate the word "ottoman" with fancy cushioned
footstools than with a mighty regime, the Ottoman Empire dominated much of
southeastern Europe and the Middle East from the fifteenth century to the end
of the First World War. In many respects it was the last of the great Muslim
empires which challenged Christian Europe, while its’ lengthy decline concerned
generations of Western statesman and its successor states still demand the
world's attention. In Osman's Dream: The
History of the Ottoman Empire, Caroline Finkel offers us a single-volume
history of the Ottoman Empire, ranging from its obscure origins to its demise
in the 1920s. Though similar overviews have been written before, her goal is to
dispel the traditional “rise and fall” approach and to free the empire from its’
stereotyping as, in her words, “a theatre of the absurd”. Tapping into the
enormous wealth of recent scholarly work on the Ottomans, she offers a far more
complex and nuanced portrayal of the empire than in most popular accounts –
pointing out, for example, that the ranks of the soldiers of the early empire
included as many Christians as it did Muslims, and that it was not until well
into the empire's decline in the 18th Century that the Ottoman
sultans began to embrace the previously disused title of Caliph.
Yet
the book suffers from a relatively narrow focus. Most of the text is dominated
by a narrative of high politics, one concentrating on the machinations and
maneuvering of the sultans; other elements, such as the complex social and
economic structures of the empire, are addressed only in passing. Moreover,
Finkel rarely explains the empire in any depth. Key institutions such as the
janissaries are mentioned and their political role is covered, but the reasons
for their existence and maintenance are rarely analyzed in detail. The result
is that while readers are informed of the who,
what, and when of Ottoman history, the how
and the why often are left
unaddressed. Furthermore, while this book provides a rather quick paced
narrative for a large span of history, its divergence from established
historical fact regarding the Armenian Genocide is so blatant as to border on
propaganda. While the author spends a short amount of time on the issue,
admitting that “some” atrocity took place (!), her views completely run counter
to a vast amount if well-established research.
Nonetheless,
Finkel has provided an accessible overview of the Ottoman Empire, one largely
free from the Eurocentric stereotyping all too typical of many earlier
histories of the subject. While the text is often dense with details, the
narrative itself is straightforward and a useful set of maps are provided to
help readers master the intricacies of the human geography of the period. This
book is likely to serve as the standard work on the empire for many years to
come, though one that should be supplemented by more explanatory texts.
No comments:
Post a Comment