354
pages, Viking Press, ISBN-13: 978-0670304325
One
of the greatest aspects of John Keegan’s impeccable writing style is that it is
always used in service to the telling the story at hand – in this case, a quite
unique and fascinating look at the literal face of battle itself, that is, at
the nature of the experience of combat from the common grunt’s perspective. Of
course, since in most of his other tomes he argues masterfully about the
integrating elements of warfare regarding set campaigns and battles in a
specific conflict, here he focuses brilliantly on the nature of organized
violence itself and how it is perceived and witnessed by the men who are so
engaged. In a very real sense, he has reversed the usual logic about conducting
war from the overall perspective and strategies of the generals and admirals
overseeing the engagement of forces to, instead, focus on the horrific and
mind-boggling perspective of the soldier on the ground – the “cipher” so often
taken for granted and ignored in historical treatments. For this reason alone
any serious student of military history should enthusiastically devour this
book.
Yet,
of course, as we devotees of Keegan’s works have come to expect and admire,
there is much more of value in this thin but provocative volume. Keegan
memorably details and describes the horror, pain, and confusion of the
battlefield and redefines our understanding of what it means to be a soldier –
from the nature of a soldier’s fears to the physical and emotional assault on
his person, covering everything from wounds to trauma to shell shock. He accurately
and articulately describes the operation of everything from field hospitals to
makeshift prisoner of war camps, and the atrocious realities involved in
experiencing either. Similarly, he briefly explores the nature of leading men
into combat, and the qualities of personality that make one a leader under such
traumatic circumstances – how it is that some men can make his fellows stand
their ground when everything around them screams for them to flee.
Combat
is surely one of the most extreme of human experiences, and as Keegan so deftly
demonstrates, it is also one of the least understood, for whether Keegan is
describing the terror of the archer attack at Agincourt, the ball and musket
charges at point blank range at Waterloo, or the hailstorm of rapid-fire
machine guns used to such horrific effect against the trench charges in the
First World War, he has captured the insanity, bravery, and futility of the
experience of war better than anyone else to date. I highly recommend this book
to any student of war or military history.
No comments:
Post a Comment