480
pages, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, ISBN-13: 978-0374283162
The
last paragraph of this book (after about 400 pages of thoughtful, nuanced and
humorous writing about selected political, cultural, and military histories of
Italy) gives the approach and the verdict of the historian on the unity of
Italy:
Geography
and the vicissitudes of history made certain countries, including France and
Britain, more important than the sum of their parts might have indicated. In
Italy the opposite was true. The parts are so stupendous that a single region –
either Tuscany or Veneto – would rival every other country in the world in the
quality of its art and the civilization of its past. But the parts have not
added up to a coherent or identifiable whole. United Italy never became the
nation its founders had hoped for because its making had been flawed both in
conception and in execution, because it had been truly what Fortunato was told
by his father, ‘a sin against history and geography’. It was thus predestined
to be a disappointment, to be what Luigi Barzini regretfully recognized many
years ago, a country that ‘has never been as good as the sum of all her
people’.”
This
book makes no pretensions to being an exhaustive, one-volume history of
nationalism and its ebb and flow in Italian history since the days of early
Rome (as if such a thing was possible, or even readable). The book does not
include any references at all to the state of San Marino, whose quirky
independence as a little nation validates the judgment of the author that the
communes of Italy are its true repositories of culture and civic virtue, such
as it exists in Italy. Reading this book with a sympathetic eye (which is not
difficult to do, as this is a work written with a great deal of panache and
sympathy) makes one long for the return of the Venetian Republic and mourn for
the loss of wealth and hope among the people of Sicily and Naples, while also
lamenting the duplicity and corruption of Italian politics for so long.
Although this book is not an all-encompassing history of Italy, it is certainly
filled with a lot of Italian language and assumes a fairly high memory for a
wide variety of figures who flit in and out of its pages in a rather elegant
manner.
The
book is organized in a way that manages to be both chronological and thematic,
taking it as a given that Italy has a wide variety of centrifugal forces that
hinder its overall unity and that certain habits of history (such as a distinct
lack of military ability on the part of Italy’s generally ineptly led armies)
are and remain enduring. Whether one is talking about the vagaries of Italian
opera or the deception of Italian politics, this book manages to present a
nuanced and articulate but clearly focused argument that Italy’s strengths have
been its rich diversity and its ability to get along, and its weaknesses have
been when its would-be leaders have attempted to induce a desired reality
rather than dealing with the reality that was and letting things occur
organically. This is, in general, a book that is clear-sighted and honest about
its heroes and manages to see the humanity even in its darker and more
villainous portrayals, retaining a love of the many Italies that the author
finds and comments upon (included are such helpful chapter titles as Imperial
Italy or Modern Italy or Republican Italy).
This
is by no means a light read, but those who undertake this book with an interest
in nations and social cohesion (or the lack thereof), as well as the lingering
problems of regionalism and the solutions that nations have for their problems
of cultural disunity in order to further the development of a common culture (I’m
looking at you, Britain), will find much to enjoy and relish in this book. This
book is like a gourmet dinner that goes down easily, full of humorous anecdotes
and gossipy chatter; of wit and humanity; and of irony and complexity befitting
its complicated subject. If one has an interest in Italian or European unity or
disunity, this book offers a great deal of intrigue in showing how Italy came
to be (and came to be so dysfunctional), an argument that the author makes that
the roots of it spring in geography (political and physical) as well as
history. Whether one agrees or disagrees with this assessment, the book is a
worthwhile and deep examination of a subject that has relevance far outside
Italy.
No comments:
Post a Comment