300
pages, St. Martin’s Press, ISBN-13: 978-0312214425
Joan
of Arc lived such a short, turbulent life, but for all that much has been
written about her and, thus, she means many things to many people: she is the
incarnation of French patriotism; she is a Fascist and mascot for
anti-Semitism; she is the symbol of working-class resistance; she is the
ultimate proto-feminist; she is the persecuted political prisoner; she is the
innocent woman prosecuted for heresy. Joan
of Arc: Her Story by Régine Pernoud and Marie-Véronique Clin, revised and
translated by Jeremy Duquesnay Adams, presents itself as the superior story of Joan
the Maid, and in many ways it is. In fact, the actual tale of Joan of Arc takes
up about half of the actual text; the remainder is a thorough index of
important people in Joan’s life with explanations, as well as another index of
important objects and events in her life with explanations. This is important
because as the authors often get bogged down in names and details in their
storytelling, the indexes serve as a supplemental reference to the main text.
Many readers may not be concerned with the significance of each character, but
those who are interested in these details will be pleased.
In
order to separate legend from fact, her uses from herself, Pernoud and Clin (and
Adams) have ingeniously turned the mystifying question Who is Joan of Arc? into the more manageable What is her record? Joan’s history was brief: a year of fighting, a
year of imprisonment. In 1429, inspired by holy “voices” she traveled to the
failing dauphin Charles (later King Charles VII) and declared that she would
free the city of Orleans from his English enemies and lead him to his
coronation. Shortly after fulfilling both prophesies, she was captured by the
English, who tried her for heresy and burned her at the stake – BUT, in 1455,
24 years after her death, a new trial concluded that the English inquisition
was improperly conducted and nullified its decision. Throughout their
descriptions of these events, the authors draw upon copious letters and trial
transcripts to present a vivid portrait of the young woman whose intelligence,
courage, determination and unshakable faith astonished all of Europe. A brief
introduction and a section of profiles of the major players make this thorough
book accessible to the general reader. Though the writing is sometimes dry,
Pernoud and Clin do an admirable job of bringing clarity to their complicated subject.
Joan
of Arc lived a life of devotion to God and to her county. With the turmoil of a
war with England that engulfed France, the country seemed destined to fall
until a peasant girl stepped to the front. Her devotion to seeing a new king of
France crowned saw her overcoming dubious odds. Unfortunately she was unable to
see the conflict to its end as she was captured and tried for heresy. Her crime
was not blasphemy, but dressing in men's clothes during battle. It was only
when she cried out Jesus’ named during execution while keeping her waning
moments of life focused on a cross that her detractors were able to see that
Joan was carrying out a mission from God. The writing of the story often moves
slowly and seems hopelessly stalled by details. While it is an interesting and
informative book, it is just not a fun read. I would suggest any person looking
for a thorough story of Joan of Arc to obtain a copy of this book.
No comments:
Post a Comment