560
pages, Penguin Books, ISBN-13: 978-0143124924
The Plantagenets:
The Warrior Kings and Queens Who Made England by Dan Jones is a spectacular history of England’s
Plantagenet dynasty from its founding by Geoffrey of Anjou to Richard II’s loss
of the Crown to Henry of Bolingbroke – i.e. from 1120 to 1399 – a timespan that
saw the signing of Magna Carta, the
conquest of Wales, and the first half of the Hundred Years’ War. The
Plantagenet kings included some of the most well-known of all English monarchs
(Richard I “the Lionheart”, bad King John, and Edward I “Longshanks”) but also several
less well-known, but equally important, monarchs (Henry II and Edward III) along
with less reputable rulers (Henry III, Edward II, and Richard II) along with
their Queens and Heirs. Be advised: this is very much a book centered on kings,
war and diplomacy, and as such it doesn’t tell dwell much (if at all) on the
everyday lot of the common medieval Englishman. Instead, it tells the hard
facts of the Plantagenet dynasty from its beginning to end.
Jones
is very instructive in debunking myths about kings. For instance John, for all
of his fearsome reputation, was no worse a tyrant than his father and older
brother and actually did his best to run a fair judicial system (so much for
the Robin Hood myth). But what John didn’t
do, that his brother and father did, was protect the realm, and he suffered
devastating military defeats at the hands of King Phillip of France, losing much
of his Angevin inheritance in the process. The loss of these lands explains
many of the problems later kings would have with their barons, as before John
lost his Angevin Empire the barons were a cross-channel aristocracy who had
every reason to support the Kings wars in France; after the losses in France (and
deprived of their estates there) most English barons saw no reason to go to war
in France or, more importantly, to pay taxes so the King could do so. Yet every
King felt the need to get the family empire back, and this issue was forever to
get English kings in trouble with their barons. The book debunks a few myths more:
Simon de Montfort was a chronic debtor who managed to take advantage of general
dissatisfaction with Henry III religious flakiness and ineffective leadership; Eleanor
of Aquitaine really was the devilish shrew as portrayed by her enemies; Edward
III, despite his much deserved reputation as the greatest English medieval
King, lost his health and vigor at the end of his life and started the rot that
Richard II completed; and so on. Jones sheds new light on every king and major
political figure of the era.
Covering
two centuries of history in a single volume is a tall order, and while Jones
succeeds the task nonetheless required certain sacrifices. The Plantagenets is a history of England, but it is one told
through the eyes of its kings and their struggle for power between with their barons.
Jones does a particularly great job at tracking the progress of the great
charters the barons kept thrusting on successive kings, and while the period
covered saw the strong elective element to kingship replaced by the more direct
method of Primogeniture, it conversely saw the devolution of power away from
the king to the barons (and, later, beyond). Jones also goes well beyond that
to show how England’s legal institutions evolved over the same period – after
1178 the royal council was stationed permanently in Westminster to hear legal
cases full-time instead of following the king wherever he went.
Dan
Jones has the three things that are necessary to write good history: the
ability to tell a good story; an eye for detail; and, perhaps most of all, the
ability to present historical figures as fully formed human beings rather than two-dimensional
caricatures. Jones manages to give the reader an understanding of his subjects
as people with strengths and faults and not just abstractions. Really one of
the better books I have read in a while.
No comments:
Post a Comment