480
pages, Mariner Books, ISBN-13: 978-0618154616
The Age of Napoleon by J. Christopher Herold is part
biography, part history, as it tells the story of Napoleon in the context of
the times he was in: political, cultural, military, economic and social, while
attempting to bring a balanced view of the man by putting him in his natural surroundings
of Europe and, though on a lesser scale, the world as it was on the verge of
modern era. This is perhaps the best thing about this book, as it covers not
only the main events that are already known to the general public but also the
affairs outside Europe or on the periphery of the main theatre. Despite all of
the criticism aimed at Napoleon’s actions, then and now, Herold shows how
Napoleon’s fellow heads of state no better than him, only less known (and less
successful). However, if you know little or nothing about the Age of Napoleon
you are in trouble, as Herold assumes you know the basic facts of the era, or that
you had read the cliff notes on his life, or that you had a basic historical
background in all of Napoleon’s battles and activities during this period.
Following these chapters can be almost almost impossible, and at times one can become
lost and be forced to re-read pages to see what one could’ve missed. Herold also
shows his general ignorance of military matters and tries to cover it by neglecting
the battles as much as possible. Imagine that: to write a critical biography of
one of the greatest generals in the history of mankind and then neglect the
field where the subject of the biography was the most successful! It’s like
writing a biography of Albert Einstein while glossing over physics, or of Henry
Ford and mentioning in passing the assembly line. Incredible.
The
author’s sneer of superiority comes across loud and clear as you read this
book, with too much space and time spent trying to prove that Napoleon, in Herold’s
humble opinion, was no genius, and too little space in actually discussing Napoleon’s
accomplishments. The author also has decided that philosophy is his forte, and
dispenses his judgments freely, much to the detriment of the book and my
opinion of the author. Herold also consistently talked down to the reader – which
I thought was rich considering this was obviously not a book for beginners or
meant to be an introduction to the period as the blurb on the back might lead
you to think – but a book written for fellow history buffs like this guy was.
He also was pretty denigrating to any theories that didn’t conform with what he
thought about what happened during the period. The almost constant negativity was
a turn off and took away from any possible enjoyment one may have had with
other, superior aspects of the book. To his credit Herold does have very droll sense
of humor, and I couldn’t help but laugh at times as he relayed some anecdote
about Napoleon…and, once he started going back and explaining in a little more
detail stuff he said before, it got to be pretty interesting. And, I admit, I
did walk away with a basic understanding of what had occurred during that time
frame. That being said, such knowledge was hard won, indeed, and I would
recommend you keep looking for a book that gives a more user friendly approach
to the Age of Napoleon.
No comments:
Post a Comment