736
pages, Basic Books, ISBN-13: 978-0465003105
Christopher
M. Andrew, an
historian at the University of Cambridge, is not new to writing about the KGB
with the assistance of prominent defectors, having written three books previously
with Oleg Gordievsky, a former colonel of the KGB, Resident-designate and
bureau chief in London (and a secret agent of the British Secret Intelligence
Service from 1974 to 1985). This time around Andrew’s coauthor was Vasili
Mitrokhin, a major and senior archivist for the First Chief Directorate of the
KGB (and a secret dissident), and their work was The Sword and the Shield: The Mitrokhin Archive and the Secret History
of the KGB. Mitrokhin took notes on the files that passed through his hands
and escaped to the West in the early 1990s with cartons of material that formed
the basis of this book. The result of their collaboration is a dense-but-illuminating
work and a must for anyone with a need and a desire to learn more about the
ways in which the deplorable Soviet Union did things.
The
book reads rather like a textbook and can be quite dry for people unfamiliar
with the subject matter; for this reason it would be best if The Sword and the Shield were not the
first book you read on the subject as it is not really meant for entertainment
but more for serious research…and make no mistake, this is a very good research
source with the information within blowing away any Hollywood spy movie. The
section on Harold Adrian Russell “Kim” Philby and the Cambridge Five alone
would make a fantastic Hollywood movie with boatloads of intrigue, sex,
betrayal and danger. And it is was all real. The important thing to keep in
mind while reading this book is that all the information was taken from the archives
of the KGB and is not some prepackaged trash designed for foreign audiences, fellow
travelers or Soviet apologists. The result is a fascinating and shocking
account of what the KGB and Soviet Union were up to in the 20th Century
(among many of the revelations that will give the American Left heartburn was the
revelation that while Joe McCarthy was overzealous in his quest to root out Communists,
he was not as crazy as history has painted him out to be in relation to the
scope of intentional Communist penetration of American government and society).
The authors are coy about naming some Soviet spies in the West, while others
found themselves compromised by Mitrokhin years ago. There are no huge
surprises here; that the KGB plotted to sabotage Western power networks,
routinely conducted assassinations through the early 1960s, and maniacally
persecuted religious groups should not shock informed readers. But the weight
of detail and the solid retelling of well-known stories, such as Soviet
recruitment of British spies in the 1930s, make for a fascinating read. Among
the more interesting conclusions is that much of the invaluable information dug
up by Soviet spies never made it through the filters of paranoia, ideology, and
sycophancy created by the Soviet leadership.
No comments:
Post a Comment